Methods
Field sampling, aquarium experiments, dissections and sediment analysis took place on Heron Island Research Station at Heron Island (23°26’S, 151°55’E), the Great Barrier Reef, Australia.
Total organic carbon content extracted by H. leucospilota from the sediment
Individuals were collected from the same area of inner reef flat off Herron Island. 10 randomly chosen, fresh individuals were collected at 10am, during which time they were observed to be feeding for the three days respectively. At this time, they were expected to have a near full gut, which was confirmed via a dissection. The 10 cucumbers were split into 2 groups of 5 individuals and were kept for a 24 hour period in clean glass tanks (free from sediment and hence food), which had a constant input of sea water. Faecal pallets were collected half an hour after the sea cucumbers were initially collected at 10:30am, then at three hours increments of 13:30, 16:30 and 1930. Faecal pallets were dried in a dehydrator and the dry weight of each sample was recorded. The samples were then cooked for a 9 hour period in a muffle furnace at 460 degrees Celsius. The weight was once again recorded and the difference in weight indicates the organic carbon content level. The percentage extracted was then calculated. This was repeated with fresh sea cucumbers from around the same area of reef flat for three consecutive days.
Organic carbon content of the sediment
Sediment was collected to compare the organic carbon content in the sand, to the content extracted by H. leucsospilota. Sediment to a maximum depth of 10mm was collected from the site where the collected H. leucospilota were collected and the same methods of drying, cooking and weighing the sand were used.
Sediment sample from the intestine of H. leucospilota
An additional specimen of H. leucospilota was collected for dissection. The intestine of the individual was extracted, which was at a filled level and the sand was removed from the membrane in what appeared to be three distinct sections. These were the osphogogus, stomach and the third section was split into post stomach and anus. Similarly to the other sediment collected it was dried, cooked and weighed.
Statistical analysis
Initially a Wilcoxon Signed-Rank Test was used to test whether there were any differences between samples collected from the two separate tanks. This tested for consistency between efficiency of extraction of organic carbon content by H. leucospilota individuals.
An Independent Two-Sample T-test was then conducted to compare the carbon percentages between the sediment in the faecal pallets, reef flat sediment and intestine samples. Initially there were a total of 12 averages of carbon content in the faecal samples. However, there was one obvious outlier in the data, (with an average of 12.033% compared to the total mean of 3.051%) which may have been a result of spilt sediment. Therefore, this sample was removed from the results, accounting for 11 samples. A preliminary test for the equality of variance was used to analyse whether the variance between groups was significantly different.
The percentages of carbon extracted were compared between all groups.
Faecal pallets verse reef flat sediment had values of F = 0.225, p = 0.022. Therefore, a Two-Sample t-Test, assuming unequal variances was used.
Faecal pallets verse the intestine had values of F = 1.244, p = 0.480. Therefore, a Two-Sample t-Test, assuming equal variances was used.
The intestine verse reef flat sediment had values of F = 4.870, p = 0.1098. Therefore, a Two-Sample t-Test, assuming equal variances was used.
If H. leucospilota is efficient at extraction it is expected there should be a difference between intestine and faecal samples verse sediment levels. Levels in the intestine and faecal pallets should be lower than in the sediment, with the faecal pallets having the lowest levels of all.
|